diff --git a/bookwyrm/static/css/fonts/icomoon.eot b/bookwyrm/static/css/fonts/icomoon.eot
index e031e7d28..c787c9bd3 100644
Binary files a/bookwyrm/static/css/fonts/icomoon.eot and b/bookwyrm/static/css/fonts/icomoon.eot differ
diff --git a/bookwyrm/static/css/fonts/icomoon.svg b/bookwyrm/static/css/fonts/icomoon.svg
index 0323df053..e58847cdf 100644
--- a/bookwyrm/static/css/fonts/icomoon.svg
+++ b/bookwyrm/static/css/fonts/icomoon.svg
@@ -30,6 +30,7 @@
 <glyph unicode="&#xe914;" glyph-name="home" horiz-adv-x="951" d="M804.571 384v-274.286c0-20-16.571-36.571-36.571-36.571h-219.429v219.429h-146.286v-219.429h-219.429c-20 0-36.571 16.571-36.571 36.571v274.286c0 1.143 0.571 2.286 0.571 3.429l328.571 270.857 328.571-270.857c0.571-1.143 0.571-2.286 0.571-3.429zM932 423.428l-35.429-42.286c-2.857-3.429-7.429-5.714-12-6.286h-1.714c-4.571 0-8.571 1.143-12 4l-395.429 329.714-395.429-329.714c-4-2.857-8.571-4.571-13.714-4-4.571 0.571-9.143 2.857-12 6.286l-35.429 42.286c-6.286 7.429-5.143 19.429 2.286 25.714l410.857 342.286c24 20 62.857 20 86.857 0l139.429-116.571v111.429c0 10.286 8 18.286 18.286 18.286h109.714c10.286 0 18.286-8 18.286-18.286v-233.143l125.143-104c7.429-6.286 8.571-18.286 2.286-25.714z" />
 <glyph unicode="&#xe915;" glyph-name="local" horiz-adv-x="1097" d="M338.857 438.857c-59.429-1.714-113.143-27.429-151.429-73.143h-76.571c-57.143 0-110.857 27.429-110.857 90.857 0 46.286-1.714 201.714 70.857 201.714 12 0 71.429-48.571 148.571-48.571 26.286 0 51.429 4.571 76 13.143-1.714-12.571-2.857-25.143-2.857-37.714 0-52 16.571-103.429 46.286-146.286zM950.857 74.857c0-92.571-61.143-148-152.571-148h-499.429c-91.429 0-152.571 55.429-152.571 148 0 129.143 30.286 327.429 197.714 327.429 19.429 0 90.286-79.429 204.571-79.429s185.143 79.429 204.571 79.429c167.429 0 197.714-198.286 197.714-327.429zM365.714 804.571c0-80.571-65.714-146.286-146.286-146.286s-146.286 65.714-146.286 146.286 65.714 146.286 146.286 146.286 146.286-65.714 146.286-146.286zM768 585.143c0-121.143-98.286-219.429-219.429-219.429s-219.429 98.286-219.429 219.429 98.286 219.429 219.429 219.429 219.429-98.286 219.429-219.429zM1097.143 456.571c0-63.429-53.714-90.857-110.857-90.857h-76.571c-38.286 45.714-92 71.429-151.429 73.143 29.714 42.857 46.286 94.286 46.286 146.286 0 12.571-1.143 25.143-2.857 37.714 24.571-8.571 49.714-13.143 76-13.143 77.143 0 136.571 48.571 148.571 48.571 72.571 0 70.857-155.429 70.857-201.714zM1024 804.571c0-80.571-65.714-146.286-146.286-146.286s-146.286 65.714-146.286 146.286 65.714 146.286 146.286 146.286 146.286-65.714 146.286-146.286z" />
 <glyph unicode="&#xe916;" glyph-name="dots-three" d="M512.051 573.44c-62.208 0-112.691-50.432-112.691-112.64s50.483-112.64 112.691-112.64c62.208 0 112.589 50.432 112.589 112.64s-50.381 112.64-112.589 112.64zM153.651 573.44c-62.208 0-112.691-50.432-112.691-112.64s50.483-112.64 112.691-112.64c62.208 0 112.589 50.483 112.589 112.64s-50.381 112.64-112.589 112.64zM870.451 573.44c-62.208 0-112.691-50.432-112.691-112.64s50.483-112.64 112.691-112.64c62.208 0 112.589 50.432 112.589 112.64s-50.381 112.64-112.589 112.64z" />
+<glyph unicode="&#xe917;" glyph-name="check" d="M424.653 102.502c-22.272 0-43.366 10.394-56.883 28.314l-182.938 241.715c-23.808 31.386-17.613 76.083 13.824 99.891 31.488 23.91 76.186 17.613 99.994-13.824l120.371-158.925 302.643 485.99c20.838 33.382 64.87 43.622 98.355 22.784 33.434-20.787 43.725-64.819 22.835-98.304l-357.581-573.952c-12.39-20.019-33.843-32.512-57.344-33.587-1.126-0.102-2.15-0.102-3.277-0.102z" />
 <glyph unicode="&#xe986;" glyph-name="search" d="M992.262 88.604l-242.552 206.294c-25.074 22.566-51.89 32.926-73.552 31.926 57.256 67.068 91.842 154.078 91.842 249.176 0 212.078-171.922 384-384 384-212.076 0-384-171.922-384-384s171.922-384 384-384c95.098 0 182.108 34.586 249.176 91.844-1-21.662 9.36-48.478 31.926-73.552l206.294-242.552c35.322-39.246 93.022-42.554 128.22-7.356s31.892 92.898-7.354 128.22zM384 320c-141.384 0-256 114.616-256 256s114.616 256 256 256 256-114.616 256-256-114.614-256-256-256z" />
 <glyph unicode="&#xe9d7;" glyph-name="star-empty" d="M1024 562.95l-353.78 51.408-158.22 320.582-158.216-320.582-353.784-51.408 256-249.538-60.432-352.352 316.432 166.358 316.432-166.358-60.434 352.352 256.002 249.538zM512 206.502l-223.462-117.48 42.676 248.83-180.786 176.222 249.84 36.304 111.732 226.396 111.736-226.396 249.836-36.304-180.788-176.222 42.678-248.83-223.462 117.48z" />
 <glyph unicode="&#xe9d8;" glyph-name="star-half" d="M1024 562.95l-353.78 51.408-158.22 320.582-158.216-320.582-353.784-51.408 256-249.538-60.432-352.352 316.432 166.358 316.432-166.358-60.434 352.352 256.002 249.538zM512 206.502l-0.942-0.496 0.942 570.768 111.736-226.396 249.836-36.304-180.788-176.222 42.678-248.83-223.462 117.48z" />
diff --git a/bookwyrm/static/css/fonts/icomoon.ttf b/bookwyrm/static/css/fonts/icomoon.ttf
index d112fb65c..8ba512daf 100644
Binary files a/bookwyrm/static/css/fonts/icomoon.ttf and b/bookwyrm/static/css/fonts/icomoon.ttf differ
diff --git a/bookwyrm/static/css/fonts/icomoon.woff b/bookwyrm/static/css/fonts/icomoon.woff
index bbac704f0..50261c681 100644
Binary files a/bookwyrm/static/css/fonts/icomoon.woff and b/bookwyrm/static/css/fonts/icomoon.woff differ
diff --git a/bookwyrm/static/css/icons.css b/bookwyrm/static/css/icons.css
index 1f34f78c8..09c22e1a2 100644
--- a/bookwyrm/static/css/icons.css
+++ b/bookwyrm/static/css/icons.css
@@ -1,10 +1,10 @@
 @font-face {
   font-family: 'icomoon';
-  src:  url('fonts/icomoon.eot?ouoizu');
-  src:  url('fonts/icomoon.eot?ouoizu#iefix') format('embedded-opentype'),
-    url('fonts/icomoon.ttf?ouoizu') format('truetype'),
-    url('fonts/icomoon.woff?ouoizu') format('woff'),
-    url('fonts/icomoon.svg?ouoizu#icomoon') format('svg');
+  src:  url('fonts/icomoon.eot?aeb2zb');
+  src:  url('fonts/icomoon.eot?aeb2zb#iefix') format('embedded-opentype'),
+    url('fonts/icomoon.ttf?aeb2zb') format('truetype'),
+    url('fonts/icomoon.woff?aeb2zb') format('woff'),
+    url('fonts/icomoon.svg?aeb2zb#icomoon') format('svg');
   font-weight: normal;
   font-style: normal;
   font-display: block;
@@ -25,6 +25,9 @@
   -moz-osx-font-smoothing: grayscale;
 }
 
+.icon-check:before {
+  content: "\e917";
+}
 .icon-dots-three:before {
   content: "\e916";
 }
diff --git a/bookwyrm/templates/snippets/shelve_button.html b/bookwyrm/templates/snippets/shelve_button.html
index b09ba2974..bf1db9b62 100644
--- a/bookwyrm/templates/snippets/shelve_button.html
+++ b/bookwyrm/templates/snippets/shelve_button.html
@@ -5,7 +5,9 @@
 {% active_shelf book as active_shelf %}
 <div class="field is-grouped">
     {% if active_shelf.identifier == 'read' %}
-    <button class="button is-small" disabled>Read ✓</button>
+    <button class="button is-small" disabled>
+        <span>Read</span> <span class="icon icon-check"></span>
+    </button>
     {% elif active_shelf.identifier == 'reading' %}
     <label class="button is-small" for="finish-reading-{{ uuid }}">
         I'm done!
@@ -42,7 +44,10 @@
                     <form class="dropdown-item pt-0 pb-0" name="shelve" action="/shelve/" method="post">
                         {% csrf_token %}
                         <input type="hidden" name="book" value="{{ book.id }}">
-                        <button class="button is-small" name="shelf" type="submit" value="{{ shelf.identifier }}" {% if shelf in book.shelf_set.all %} disabled {% endif %}>{{ shelf.name }} {% if shelf in book.shelf_set.all %} ✓ {% endif %}</button>
+                        <button class="button is-small" name="shelf" type="submit" value="{{ shelf.identifier }}" {% if shelf in book.shelf_set.all %} disabled {% endif %}>
+                            <span>{{ shelf.name }}</span>
+                            {% if shelf in book.shelf_set.all %}<span class="icon icon-check"></span>{% endif %}
+                        </button>
                     </form>
                     {% endif %}
                 </li>